Guide 16 min read

Self-employed or limited company Spain: the day-0 decision

Day 0 in common-scheme Spain: self-employed or SL. Personal liability, company tax ID, RETA versus Corporation Tax and incorporation cost.

Unused brass company seal press, personal notepad and fountain pen on grey slate

Day 0 is not about picking a Corporation Tax rate. It is about the legal subject of the business: the person who signs with the client, appears on the invoice, faces a claim and pays Social Security. Self-employed or limited company Spain means two different legal persons. A natural-person autónomo and a sociedad limitada (SL) answer those questions differently. Treating the choice as a fiscal shortcut usually costs more than it saves.

On day 0 you are not choosing a Corporation Tax rate: you are choosing the legal person that will sign contracts and carry the activity debts. There is no statutory turnover threshold that forces you to incorporate a limited company under Spain’s common scheme. The Corporate Enterprises Act defines the SL through capital, legal personality and shareholder liability, not through an income volume. Corporate Enterprises Act, Articles 1 to 4 Day 0 picks the contracting party and the debt bearer; it does not yet lock a closed tax rate.

This guide is for someone who has not started yet, or is about to start, under the common scheme. If you already trade as an autónomo and are weighing the jump, the file changes: inventory, cut-off date and a twelve-month model. That analysis lives in freelancer to limited company: when to switch. This page does not rewrite that work.

A natural-person self-employed worker carries on an economic or professional activity on their own account, habitually, personally and directly, outside another person’s organisation. That is how Article 1 of the Self-Employed Workers Statute defines it. Self-Employed Workers Statute, Article 1 Contracts show your personal NIF. You can use a trading name; that name alone does not create a separate legal person.

A limited liability company is a capital company. Capital is divided into shares and made up of the shareholders’ contributions; those shareholders do not personally answer for the company debts. Corporate Enterprises Act, Article 1.2 On inscription in the Mercantile Registry the company acquires the legal personality of the type chosen. Corporate Enterprises Act, Article 33

That separation only counts if you respect it: contracts in the company’s name, its own accounts, coherent invoices and documented decisions. Having the SL on the Registry and still signing everything personally is a disguise, not a structure.

Liability: person, shareholder, director and guarantee

As a natural-person autónomo, the general rules on obligations reach you fully. The debtor answers for the performance of obligations with all present and future assets. Civil Code, Article 1911 That does not mean every incident ends in attachment: you still have to identify the debt, the obliged party and the defences. It does mean that RETA registration does not create the asset separation of a capital company.

The debtor answers for the performance of obligations with all present and future assets. In a limited liability company, the shareholders do not personally answer for the company debts. Corporate Enterprises Act, Article 1.2 In the SL, ordinary debt incurred by the company belongs to the company. Shareholders do not personally answer for those company debts. Corporate Enterprises Act, Article 1.2 “Limited liability” is not personal immunity. The same conversation usually mixes four layers:

  1. Autónomo assets. The natural person answers for what they incurred.
  2. Company assets. The SL answers for what it incurred after existing as a legal person.
  3. Director office. Directors answer to the company, the shareholders and the company creditors for damage caused by acts or omissions contrary to the law or the articles, or by failing in the duties of the office, where there is intent or fault. Corporate Enterprises Act, Article 236
  4. Personal guarantee. By surety you bind yourself to pay or perform for a third party if that party does not. Civil Code, Article 1822 A bank, landlord or supplier can ask you to guarantee even when the company is the principal debtor.

The Tax Agency can also derive liability for the legal person’s debts onto the director in the cases set out in the General Tax Act. Article 43 regulates secondary liable parties, including de facto or de jure directors in certain infringement or cessation situations. General Tax Act, Article 43; AEAT: secondary liability, responsible parties and successors The operational detail of how that risk lands is in director secondary liability for Spanish SL tax debts; here it is enough to know that forming an SL does not switch that route off.

Before you choose a form, write what you will sign in four columns: personal obligations, obligations of the future company, guarantees or sureties in your name, and director duties. If a draft mixes those positions, ask for clarification before you sign.

When the market asks for a company tax ID

No common-scheme rule forces you to create an SL merely because you invoice a lot. A client can make hiring you conditional on operating through a legal person. Corporate clients, B2B marketplaces, supplier portals and some tenders require a legal person and its entity NIF (the familiar company CIF).

In the public sector, the general rule admits natural or legal persons with capacity to act, without a contracting prohibition and with the required solvency. Public Sector Contracts Act, Article 65 That does not stop a specific tender from asking for organisation, classification or form requirements that, in practice, only a company meets. Read the tender document rather than the notice headline.

In the private market there is no single legal catalogue. Some buyers only onboard company suppliers. Platforms may condition catalogues or limits on an entity tax ID, and large accounts sometimes copy compliance filters built for companies. If your first large client already wrote that into the supplier questionnaire, that condition outweighs any blog threshold.

Do not confuse a natural-person NIF with an entity NIF either. The autónomo invoices with personal identification. The company, once incorporated and identified with AEAT, invoices with its own. If the client requires the second and you only have the first, no trading-name trick replaces it.

When a company tax ID is the only real reason to incorporate, also price the annual cost of keeping the company alive. A registered shell still generates obligations. AEAT reminds that inactive companies remain obliged to file the Corporation Tax return on the terms of the manual. AEAT: inactive companies

RETA versus Corporation Tax: an opening filter, not a verdict

The day-0 tax filter is not a rate table. It is knowing which tax charges which person, and which Social Security contribution travels with the natural person.

As an autónomo, net activity income enters your IRPF. The RETA contribution is your Social Security cover; its amount depends on the estimated net-income bracket and the contribution base chosen inside that bracket under the current system. Royal Decree-Law 13/2022; Importass: public RETA contribution simulator Registration and contribution details sit in the Spanish-language guides self-employed registration and self-employed contribution. This page does not recalculate tables: they change by rule and by your bracket.

A resident limited company is, as a rule, a Corporation Tax taxpayer. Taxpayers, when resident in Spanish territory, are legal persons (with the statutory exclusions, such as certain civil partnerships without a commercial object) and other entities listed in the Act. Corporate Income Tax Act, Article 7; AEAT: taxpayer entities Applicable rates, temporary scales and the exclusions from the 15% new-entity rate are treated in the Spanish Corporation Tax guide and, for someone already trading, in the switch guide. They are not repeated here: a loose figure without checking eligibility makes the day-0 decision worse.

Three short points cut the usual mistake:

  • The RETA contribution is not Corporation Tax. One is Social Security for the person; the other taxes the entity’s income.
  • Creating an SL does not automatically switch off RETA contributions. Someone who directs or provides services to a capital company with effective control can remain inside RETA. Effective control exists, in any event, when the worker owns at least half the capital. It is also presumed, unless proved otherwise, when at least half the capital is held jointly by shareholders with whom the worker lives and to whom the worker is linked by marriage, blood relationship, affinity or adoption up to the second degree; when the worker owns at least one third; or when the worker owns at least one quarter and also performs management and direction functions. General Social Security Act, Article 305.2(b) Daily life inside an already formed SL (contribution, director pay, dividends and withholdings) is in corporate self-employed: Social Security, IRPF and payroll.
  • Company money is not shareholder money. Collecting into the SL account and taking it out without a legal basis (remuneration, dividend, loan repayment) is not a minor bookkeeping detail: it is the core of the real tax comparison.

If almost all year-one profit goes to mortgage, food and personal spending, the SL adds paperwork without leaving much inside. If a share can stay for equipment, working capital or other partners, the comparison starts to matter. Treat it as a cash filter, not a tax verdict.

Incorporation cost and formality (without rewriting the resource guides)

The law allows an SL to be formed with one euro of capital. Until capital plus the legal reserve reaches three thousand euros, at least 20% of profit must go to that reserve; and if the company is wound up without enough assets, the shareholders answer jointly and severally for the difference between three thousand euros and the subscribed capital. Corporate Enterprises Act, Article 4 That euro is contributed capital, not a fee and not a tax saving.

Directors must draw up the annual accounts within three months of the financial year-end, and file them at the Mercantile Registry after approval. Corporate Enterprises Act, Articles 253 and 279 Those annual duties weigh more than the notary fee on the deed.

For the practical folder (name, DUE/CIRCE, notary, contributions), use the resource guides and do not improvise from internet lists. These Spanish-language pages cover the steps:

If you work alone and want a short SLU versus natural-person matrix, that is also in Spanish at sole-shareholder limited company or self-employed. This page does not duplicate that matrix.

To operate as a natural-person autónomo you usually need a census declaration (form 036) and RETA registration before the activity begins. For an SL, legal personality arises on Mercantile Registry inscription after the deed and incorporation formalities.

Starting as self-employed is not zero paperwork either: a census declaration (form 036) and RETA registration before the activity begins. AEAT: form 036; Importass: self-employed worker registration The concrete sequence is in the Spanish registration guide cited above.

Decision rule: self-employed or limited company

There is no automatic formula. There is a working rule to order the evidence before you pay a notary or register.

Lean toward self-employed if no client requires a company tax ID and almost all profit is withdrawn for personal spending. Lean toward an SL when contractual risk is material, there are several partners, or there is a commercial or tender condition that only a legal person can meet. It is a working rule drawn from the subject and liability framework of the Corporate Enterprises Act, not an automatic legal test. In the first scenario, the natural person is usually the simplest way to start without loading mercantile duties you will not use. In the second, the SL is doing real work rather than sitting as decoration.

There is a grey zone. A professional who invoices SMEs, with no company tax ID required and no partners, can spend years as an autónomo with solid cover. A distribution business that signs financing in month one usually looks at the SL from the outset. The Spanish SLU or self-employed matrix orders questions if you are a sole shareholder; it does not replace reading the contract on the table.

If you already trade and the doubt is when to switch, go back to freelancer to limited company: when to switch. Day 0 and day 400 do not fit in the same file.

Three day-0 scenarios (hypothetical)

The following cases are hypothetical. They are not tax forecasts and not a quote.

Professional services to SMEs, no partners. You expect €35,000 of income and €12,000 of deductible costs in year one. No client has asked for a company tax ID. You withdraw almost everything to live on. Here the natural-person autónomo usually suffices: census, RETA registration, professional insurance and clear contracts. Forming an SL would add annual accounts and a banking layer without the market requiring it.

Two technical partners with a corporate client. The supplier onboarding questionnaire asks for an entity NIF and an account in the company’s name. There will be advances and an SLA with penalties. Here the legal person is not a tax whim: it is the form the contract already assumes. You still need to read guarantees, the shareholders’ agreement and who contributes in RETA if there is effective control.

Distribution with stock and a credit facility. The bank offers financing to the company if the shareholder guarantees it. The SL separates stock and suppliers from personal assets on ordinary company debts, but the guarantee reopens personal exposure on that contract. Day 0 must compare the cost of forming and keeping the company with the real size of the commercial risk, not with a generic promise of “total protection”.

Across those cases the useful question stays the same: which document will bind you next week. If there is still no document, write the assumptions down before you pay a notary.

What does not decide the choice (and usually confuses it)

You will hear firm-sounding lines about self-employed or limited company Spain. Check them against the law:

  • “Above X euros you must be a company.” There is no such legal threshold in the common scheme. A popular figure can warn that it is time to model; it does not replace the legal person or the contract.
  • “With an SL I do not pay autónomo contributions.” False as a rule. RETA classification of shareholders and directors with effective control still follows the General Social Security Act rules cited above.
  • “The 15% Corporation Tax rate already makes it worth incorporating.” That reduced rate has requirements and exclusions; and on day 0 almost nobody has a real taxable base to model with care. See the Spanish Corporation Tax guide and the switch guide for someone already trading.
  • “Starting as self-employed closes the door to an SL.” No. Many businesses begin as a natural person and incorporate when a required tax ID, a partner or a different risk appears. The cost sits in documenting the later transfer well, not in the initial choice itself.

Separate three calendars: census and RETA (natural person), deed and inscription (company), and the first material contract. If the contract arrives before inscription, do not invent an invoice in the name of an SL in formation without professional criteria: provisional NIF and entity documentation have their own AEAT rules.

Short checklist before you choose

Before you register or reserve a name, answer in writing:

  1. Who will sign the first client contract and the critical supplier contract?
  2. Does any questionnaire, tender or platform already require an entity NIF?
  3. Will there be partners other than you in the next twelve months?
  4. Which guarantees or sureties have the bank, landlord or client already floated?
  5. How much foreseeable profit will you withdraw for personal spending in year 1?
  6. Are you willing to draw up and file annual accounts every year if you choose an SL?
  7. Does your activity require a professional college, an authorisation or a specific company form?

If you cannot answer the first four with documents or drafts, you do not yet have a decision. You have a preference. Discuss preferences; sign documents.

Limitations

This guide is limited to the common state scheme: it does not resolve the Basque Country or Navarre in their foral layer, or the Canary Islands for anything that is not state law. It is not personalised advice and it does not replace a written engagement with a professional. The company framework cited is that of the Corporate Enterprises Act and the Self-Employed Workers Statute in common territory. It also does not cover labour companies, cooperatives, communities of goods, or the analysis of a specific regulated activity whose colleges or authorisations impose their own form.

Nor does it treat an SL as full protection or self-employed as always cheaper. Legal form is a tool. The contract, the guarantee and the director’s conduct decide much of the risk. Contributions, Corporation Tax rates and notary fees change, so this page links official resources and living guides instead of pinning a table that goes stale.

Next step

If the day-0 decision turns on legal issues (articles, partners, guarantees, tender), start with legal advisory with the drafts on the table. If the bottleneck is census, IRPF/Corporation Tax or the RETA fit, add tax and accounting advisory.

If you already invoice as an autónomo and the question is the jump, do not use this page as a transition manual: go to freelancer to limited company: when to switch. If the SL already exists and the tangle is contribution plus director payroll, use corporate self-employed: Social Security, IRPF and payroll.

Frequently asked questions

Is there a turnover threshold that forces you to create an SL on day 0?

No. No common-scheme rule sets an income volume at which you must incorporate a limited company. You choose the legal person that will contract and bear liability; turnover alone does not open or close that door.

If I form an SL, do I stop answering with my personal assets?

As a shareholder, you do not personally answer for ordinary company debts. You remain exposed if you sign a guarantee or surety, if you take obligations in your own name, or if, as a director, you breach duties the law attaches to the office. The SL label does not cancel those routes.

Can a client or a public tender require a company tax ID?

Yes, as a contractual or tender condition. Public-sector contracting law admits natural and legal persons; a specific tender can still demand organisational requirements that only a company meets. In the private market, platforms and buyers can require an entity tax ID without any general legal turnover threshold.

Does starting as self-employed mean I pay Corporation Tax?

No. A natural-person autónomo declares business income under Personal Income Tax (IRPF). Corporation Tax charges resident entities. The RETA contribution is the person’s Social Security cover; it does not replace or equal Corporation Tax.

Can I start as self-employed and move to an SL later?

Yes. Many businesses begin as a natural person and incorporate only when a client requires a company, several partners appear, or contractual risk becomes material. That later jump needs an inventory, a cut-off date and a twelve-month model; it is not the same problem as the day-0 choice.

Does this guide cover the Basque Country or Navarre?

No. It is limited to the common state scheme. The foral territories and, for anything that is not state law, the Canary Islands sit outside. It also does not replace a personalised review of your activity, contracts or tax domicile.

Sources